viernes, 13 de septiembre de 2013

El nuevo logo de Yahoo es más cosmético

Yahoo’s new logo makes it look more like a cosmetics brand than an internet company

By Jeff Yang
Jeff Yang writes about technology, culture and the intersection between them. He lives in New York City, has written several books and contributes regularly to National Public Radio.


Mayer worked with a four-person design team on the new logo. Reuters/Beck Diefenbach

There’s no question that CEO Marissa Mayer has people looking anew at beleaguered old-guard portal Yahoo. Enough to get pundits to stop using adjectives like “beleaguered”? The jury’s still out. But the stock price is moving in the right direction, employee morale is up—even among those who were asked to sto telecommuting—and the deft acquisition of Tumblr and a flurry of smaller startups points to a desire to swing for the fences and write a new, future-facing story for one of the internet’s original superbrands.
+
Somewhere along the way, Meyer clearly decided that this “new story” required a different cover: Over the last 30 days, dubbed the “30 Days of Change,” Yahoo! has unveiled a different new logo every day, all representing potential replacements for its 18-year-old visual yodel.
+
It got the company a lot of mileage, says Julie Cottineau, founder and CEO of digital brand consultancy BrandTwist. “They showed people the visual process rather than simply presenting one big reveal.”
+
The parade of concepts culminated this week, with the 30th and ostensibly final iteration unveiled—a more austere and streamlined logo that, in Mayer’s own words, aimed at being “whimsical, yet sophisticated. Modern and fresh, with a nod to our history. Having a human touch, personal. Proud.”
+
Meyer says she “rolled up her sleeves and dove into the trenches” with her four-person design team to create the final look. Given her famously hands-on approach, it’s likely that no aspect of Yahoo!’s transformation has more fingerprints on it than this redesign.
+
“She wanted her identity to be left on the mark,” says Laura Ries, president of Atlanta-based marketing strategy firm Ries & Ries and author of the book Visual Hammer. “She’s given the logo her own personal touch.”
+
And so it is unfortunate that this may be Meyer’s first big public failure.
+
Even before the unveiling of the winning design, Larry Popelka of Bloomberg BusinessWeek’s Management Blog suggested that the project “may be the biggest mistake in Marissa Mayer’s nascent career as chief executive officer”—since logo designs are far less likely to increase business than “make CEOs look silly.”
+
Now that Yahoo!’s new hotness is out, the reactions seem to confirm Popelka’s warning. TechCrunch founder and CrunchFund principal Mike Arrington called it “godawful,” “boring, “banal,” and “fugly”—“a horse designed by committee” that “looks like a logo that someone would have created with clipart fonts from those CDs back in the early ’90s.” Skift CEO Rafat Ali snarked that the logo made him feel “cheated and violated.” Perhaps most damning was a tweet from serial entrepreneur Derek Pozawek, who noted that “It looks like a gravestone. It probably is.”
+
That’s not the only thing that the chiseled-looking, faintly curved semi-serif logo resembles. As a follower of AllThingsD’s Kara Swisher pointed out on her Twitter feed, the typeface (apparently adapted from the well-known face Optima) has an uncanny resemblance to the font used by cosmetics brand Clinique.
+
And therein lies a major problem for Yahoo. If it were just Clinique, the resemblance might be passed off as an offhand coincidence. A wider scan readily shows just how common the use of Optima-esque fonts is in the broader beauty and personal care category, with global brands ranging from Revlon, Estée Lauder, CoverGirl, Olay and Redken all using similar-looking variations of the face.
+
yahoo_beauty2
BrandTwist’s Cottineau describes the aesthetic Meyer seems to have been seeking as “sleek,” “modern” and “premium”—but these aren’t adjectives that are naturally associated with Yahoo’s brand essence, which, Cottineau notes, is better described as “friendly, energetic and accessible.”
+
And that creates a jarring sense of disconnect not just between Yahoo’s past and its intended future, but also between Yahoo and its digital peers and rivals.
+
Visual Hammer’s Laura Ries notes that one of the primary functions of a logo is to “identify a brand in a crowd.” But what if a logo divorces a brand from its crowd entirely?
+
As this comparison shows, other than a handful of niche e-commerce startups, such as daily deals site Gilt Groupe, most online brands are marked by a sensibility that blends visual whimsy and abstract, “flat” design. The combination underscores both the disruptive and unconventional character of the Internet at large and the brands’ desire for broad-based, boundary-free appeal.
+
Slide2
Cosmetics and personal care brands, meanwhile, tend to invoke elitism, elegance and heritage; even if they’re widely available, they play to aspirations for products that are niche-focused, costly and tied to a long and illustrious legacy.
+
These aren’t exactly the image Yahoo needs to convey to consumers, given that it’s perhaps the most “mass” of mass Internet brands, with a business largely dependent on free content and—if anything—is trying to get its users to think forward and not back.
+

This has ominous implications for Mayer’s larger transformation campaign. As brand consultant and former Ant Hill principal Kim Brater notes, the key for a successful rebranding is whether the new identity reflects a true change of vision. “What is Yahoo’s essence? What is their brand promise?—I don’t know. Does their internal team know?” she asks. “Companies with crappy logos can still deliver on their promise, while those that spend millions on redesign can still fail. The logo shift for Yahoo—I’m not sure it was essential for brand delivery at this point.”
1
In other words, if Yahoo’s facelift is as “cosmetic” as it appears, Mayer’s apparent run of success could be no more than skin deep.

Follow Jeff on Twitter at @originalspin. We welcome your comments atideas@qz.com.

4 comentarios:

Daniel Arjan dijo...

Hola,
Soy Juan Diego, un prestamista privado de préstamos que da préstamos oportunidad de tiempo de vida. ¿Necesita un préstamo urgente para pagar sus deudas o necesita un préstamo para mejorar su negocio? Usted ha sido rechazada por los bancos y otras instituciones financieras? ¿Necesita un préstamo de consolidación o hipoteca? en busca de más, porque estamos aquí para hacer que todos sus problemas financieros en una cosa del pasado. Nos prestan fondos a las personas que necesitan asistencia financiera, que tienen un mal crédito o en necesidad de dinero para pagar las facturas, para invertir en el negocio a una tasa del 2%. Quiero utilizar este medio para informarle de que se proporciona una asistencia fiable y beneficiario y estaremos dispuestos a ofrecerle un préstamo. Así que póngase en contacto con nosotros hoy mismo por correo electrónico a:
(diegosaintloans@outlook.com)

Bishop T.D Jakes dijo...

Hola,
Soy Obispo T.D Jakes, un prestamista privado de préstamos que da préstamos oportunidad de tiempo de vida. ¿Está usted en cualquier tipo de dificultades financieras? Necesita un préstamo para la consolidación de deuda, la construcción, préstamo de bienes raíces, refinanciar,, el objetivo comercial personal o dinero de emergencia? ¿Es usted un hombre de negocios o las mujeres que están pensando en ampliar su oferta de préstamo de negocios de todo tipo. si está interesado en contacto con nosotros hoy a través de (bishopjakesloancompany@gmail.com)

Ben Peterson dijo...

Hola,
Soy el Dr. Ben Peterson, un prestamista de préstamos privados que da préstamos de oportunidad de tiempo de vida. ¿Está usted en algún tipo de dificultades financieras? Necesita un préstamo para la consolidación de deudas, a una tasa de 2% de construcción, préstamo de bienes raíces, refinanciación, personal, propósito comercial o dinero de emergencia? ¿Es usted un hombre de negocios o las mujeres que están pensando en ampliar su negocio ofreciendo préstamos de todo tipo. Si está interesado contacte con nosotros hoy a través de (24hoursloanservices@gmail.com)

Jeniffer Williams dijo...

Hola,

Somos una organización cristiana fundada para ayudar a las personas en Necesidades ayudar, tales como ayuda financiera para ayudar. Así que si usted está pasando por dificultades financieras o están en cualquier lío financiero, y necesita fondos para iniciar su propio negocio, o tiene que prestar a sus deudas liquidar o pagar sus cuentas, iniciar un buen negocio, o le resulta difícil Préstamo de capital para obtener los bancos locales, por favor, póngase en contacto con nosotros hoy por e-mail mrsjenifferwilliams.uk@gmail.com para la Biblia dice: "Lucas 11:10 Todo el mundo, pide recibe, El que busca encuentra, y al que llama, la voluntad abrió". Así que pase esta oportunidad porque Jesús es el mismo ayer, hoy y siempre. Por favor, esto es para personas serias y temerosas de Dios.

Tu nombre:
SEXO:
AÑOS:
país:
Monto del préstamo:
Duración del préstamo:
Propósito del Préstamo:
Su ingreso mensual:
Ocupación:
Número de teléfono válido:
¿Ha solicitado un préstamo antes de:
Gracias por su comprensión, su información de contacto, mientras esperamos

saludos
administración
E-mail: mrsjenifferwilliams.uk@gmail.com

Publicar un comentario

Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More

 
Design by Free WordPress Themes | Bloggerized by Lasantha - Premium Blogger Themes | Best Hostgator Coupon Code